Trinity St Clair thinks she's homely compared to her hot step sister Megan Rain. She hates that Megan steals her clothes and wears them better, and steals her boyfriends who like her better. Megan the cheerleader is always going to win. Even when Trinity goes into her bedroom to watch some porn and masturbate her pussy, Megan barges in and makes it a competition; who can cum the fastest. When Trinity indeed loses to her more orgasmic sister, Megan comes up with something a little more challenging. She concocts a creampie competition to see whose pussy the pizza delivery guy would rather cum inside. When Xander Corvus shows up with the pizzas, greeted by two gorgeous teens in bra and panties, he begins to realize that they plan on devouring him! After a duel of blow jobs, the girls eat pussy while Xander fucks their holes, until he loses his load and creampies in the winning pussy. Which one of the creampie sisters will it be?